Uma lição da “Grande Depressão”

“The NRA: How Price-Fixing Perpetuated the Great Depression” de Burton Folsom, Jr. (The Freeman)

Some observers seem to think employers are less willing than employees to seek federal help, so the actual case is revealing. The National Industrial Recovery Act (soon shortened to NRA) became law under President Franklin Roosevelt in 1933 and dramatically altered America’s traditional free-market system. Under the NRA, a majority of firms in any industry had government approval backed by force to determine how much a factory could expand, what wages had to be paid, the number of hours to be worked, and the prices of products. Whether or not a businessman helped write the code for his industry, he was bound by the terms and subject to a fine or jail term if he violated them.

Why were Roosevelt and certain New Dealers so eager for higher wages and prices without an increase in productivity and with less competition? They believed that if people earned more, they could buy more, and that would stimulate recovery from the Great Depression. In this high-wage theory the efficient, innovative, and price-cutting businessman was evil because he was believed to contribute to lower wages and therefore diminishing purchasing power. He was a violator of “fair competition.” His gain was not just the loss of his competitors but of the whole country. By encouraging codes of “fair competition,” the NRA was giving all existing businesses a chance to make profits, to pay high wages, and to survive the price-cutter.

Many businessmen liked the idea of raising their prices and sending to jail any competitor who wanted to charge lower prices. But such a move discouraged inventors and entrepreneurs from experimenting with ways to make products cheaper and better. The NRA in effect carved up markets among existing producers, fixed prices and wages, and assumed all industry was stagnant and unchanging. In automobiles, however, Henry Ford had experimented with assembly-line production and had cut the price of American cars from about $3,000 to $300. Under the NRA he was not allowed to innovate further. So Ford refused to sign the code and jack up his car prices, as his competitors at General Motors and Chrysler were doing. “I do not think that this country is ready to be treated like Russia for awhile,” Ford wrote in his notebook. “There is a lot of that pioneer spirit here yet.”

Ford was told his company would receive no government contracts until he signed—and with the large increase in government agencies during the 1930s, that meant a huge loss of business. For example, the government rejected a Ford agency bid on 500 trucks for the Civilian Conservation Corps that was $169,000 below the next best offer. “We have got to eliminate the purchase of Ford cars [by the government because the company has not] gone along with the general [NRA] agreement,” Roosevelt said at a press conference.

Ford’s assertion of freedom and independence gave hope to those who wanted to return to competition.

Um pensamento sobre “Uma lição da “Grande Depressão”

  1. CN

    A estapafúrdia tentativa de combater a doença combatendo o processo de cura que se manifesta: Deflaçãofobia no seu melhor.

    Impediram assim os salários de descer, impedindo o desemprego de ser minimizado. Existia uma frase corrente na altura que era: “nem é mau, se mantiveres o emprego”, tomara, os preços caíam e o poder de compra aumentava.. à custa do desemprego dos outros.

    Na altura até destruíram colheitas e matavam porcos para os preços não caírem.

    Loucos varridos, e ainda ficam com louros. A retória (à la Roosevelt) e fascínio que provocava nas massas era o mesmo de por Mussolini ou outros.

Deixe uma Resposta

Preencha os seus detalhes abaixo ou clique num ícone para iniciar sessão:

Logótipo da

Está a comentar usando a sua conta Terminar Sessão /  Alterar )

Google photo

Está a comentar usando a sua conta Google Terminar Sessão /  Alterar )

Imagem do Twitter

Está a comentar usando a sua conta Twitter Terminar Sessão /  Alterar )

Facebook photo

Está a comentar usando a sua conta Facebook Terminar Sessão /  Alterar )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.